The W3C Credentials Community Group

Meeting Transcriptions and Audio Recordings (2014-today)

Go Back


Telecon

Minutes for 2021-09-21

Juan Caballero is scribing.
Manu Sporny: Agenda review
... lots of PRs to review
Mahmoud Alkhraishi: +1
Mike Prorock: +1
Joe Andrieu: +1
Orie Steele: Call times for PRs is fine, but could we come up with a codeowner independent merge consensus?
... async work mode would be helpful
Manu Sporny: SGTM, lots of +1s in chat
Juan Caballero: +1
<mprorock> Whoo hoo!!!! thanks Joe
Joe Andrieu: Mike Proroclk and Orie Steele have worked with me and Eric to map out the flow of that use-case in more detail
... the mapping exercise teased out some edits to the usecase and it's really helpful
... to the editorial process
... I will add that URL to the minutes shortly
Manu Sporny: Intros and Reintros
<joe_andrieu> the sequence diagram email in the archives: https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-credentials/2021Sep/0109.html

Topic: Introductions and Reintroductions

Kerri Lemoie: Co-chairing VC-EDU and schedule just allowed me to attend these this week! Excited to be here
Manu Sporny: For those of you that don't know Kerri, she is awesome.
<joe_andrieu> Hi Kerri!
Juan Caballero: +1 To awesomeness
<kerri_lemoie> Thanks Manu :)

Topic: Merge Windows

Orie Steele: Since this isn't a formal WG, we should leverage that freedom and work faster, particularly since working fast increases chances of this going standards track later
... aiming for faster PRs, more frequent PRs, and operate under the "UNSTABLE COMMUNITY DRAFT" banner
... merging major changes with positive feedback and 1 or 2 reviews could be merged on day 7 without discussion on call, and minor PRs even faster, is a policy i would support
... I would recommend no PR stay open over a week if there are no changes requested by 2+ reviewers
<orie> yes
Manu Sporny: To clarify, editorial and non-substantive at discretion of editors, for substantive feedback, leave open for 7 or longer if it takes longer to resolve change requests
<orie> PROPOSAL 1: Any editorial PR can be merged as soon as 2 code owners approve the PR.
<orie> PROPOSAL 2: Any none editorial PR can be merged as soon as 2 code owners approve the PR, and its been open without change request for a minimum of 7 days.
PROPOSAL: Any editorial PR can be merged as soon as 2 code owners approve the PR.
Manu Sporny: +1
Joe Andrieu: +1
Orie Steele: +1
Mike Prorock: +1
Mahmoud Alkhraishi: +1
Adrian Gropper: +1
Juan Caballero: +1
RESOLUTION: Any editorial PR can be merged as soon as 2 code owners approve the PR.
PROPOSAL: Any none editorial PR can be merged as soon as 2 code owners approve the PR, and its been open without change request for a minimum of 7 days.
Mike Prorock: +1 Lots of gaming on that kind of thing
Mahmoud Alkhraishi: 7 Days since last change req?
<orie> YES
Manu Sporny: But that opens the door to a lot of gaming
Mahmoud Alkhraishi: Would adding code owners req'd for approval help?
Orie Steele: I don't think that helps, 2 will tag the 3rd if there's a problem
... and besides if our codeowners can't triage this many PRs in a timely manner we can get new ones
... and we should use change request feature in github to be very clear and direct
... even if the change request is "i will not support any form of this PR" (written into the CR window of the GH interface)
Orie Steele: +1 To being early in the game... we should not be processing contributors to death...
Mike Prorock: +1 Joe - it is also pretty easy to go put another PR in to adjust something as needed
Joe Andrieu: I think we should remind ourselves we're in INCUBATION MODE and other processes in incubation mode work in google docs and very quickly
<brent> I think 7 days is fine, especially in view of the desired iterative process.
... so we shouldn't let the GH format put us into a very deliberative process autopilot
Manu Sporny: I sympathize with both sides of this, we can't be too cautious but there are reasons to be cautious even though we're at such an early stage
<mahmoud> happy 2 or 3
... so we can go ahead with Brent's version, then, if Mahmoud is happy
PROPOSAL: Any non-editorial PR can be merged as soon as 2 code owners approve the PR, if it has been open for a minimum of 7 days and change requests have been addressed.
Mahmoud Alkhraishi: +1
Manu Sporny: +1
Brent Zundel: +1
Mike Prorock: +1
Orie Steele: +1
Adrian Gropper: +1
Joe Andrieu: +1
Juan Caballero: +1
Eric Schuh: +1
RESOLUTION: Any non-editorial PR can be merged as soon as 2 code owners approve the PR, if it has been open for a minimum of 7 days and change requests have been addressed.
Manu Sporny: That work for you, Orie?
Orie Steele: Yup, I might suggest we start using this immediately (like, the rest of this call)

Topic: Renaming VC HTTP API to VC API

Mike Prorock: You can't object to non-resolutions
...it was informative, so no action needs to be taken to the "formal" objection
Manu Sporny: Call for objections to renaming
No objections raised
PROPOSAL: Rename the VC HTTP API to become the VC API.
Orie Steele: +1
Manu Sporny: <Types proposal while reading it out loud>
Manu Sporny: +1
Mahmoud Alkhraishi: +1
Juan Caballero: +1
<joe_andrieu> +100
Kerri Lemoie: +1
Mike Prorock: +1
Adrian Gropper: +1
Juan Caballero: I feel you, Joe
Brent Zundel: -0
<mprorock> lol
<mprorock> yes
<kerri_lemoie> HaH
RESOLUTION: Rename the VC HTTP API to become the VC API.
Joe Andrieu: Just want to remark a famous remark of Tim Berners-Lee that he would never have named it HTTP if he'd known people would be saying URLs out loud every day
<orie> its cool, some browser vendors hide it anyway...
<manu> Just to clarify, the full name of the renamed specification should be "The Verifiable Credential API"
<mprorock> i insist on RPC /s
Justin Richer: Did:vc:soap
Orie Steele: +1 To soap.
<justin_richer> why does : vc : turn into :vc: here??
<justin_richer> (jitsie has a flag, fwiw)
^ ��

Topic: Pull Request 224 - Resolutions in Spec

Mike Prorock: +1 To closing
<orie> please close confusing and outdated PRs.
<mahmoud> close
Joe Andrieu: +1 To close
<mprorock> we can cherry pick good language out to use in other PRs
<orie> 9

Topic: Pull Request 226 - RAR and GNAP

Manu Sporny: Thanks to Justin for writing this up, lots of discussion. some of this content has been moved to other PRs
Manu Sporny: How should we move forward with this, workflow and order of operations a little confusing
Justin Richer: I marked this as a draft so as NOT to be merged. I put this in as a straw man/examples of the language the group *could* write
... i think open or closed, this PR would be a good thing to cut and paste. I wanted it in the repo because I felt words kept getting put in my mouth
Mike Prorock: +1 Some very good language in here - note I think a lot has already been pulled out into other PRs
... I think this group has been happy to do things like work with scope strings, and I think the comments in this thread are good questions about designing APIs with actions in mind
<orie> I provided feedback on the PR, but it has not been addressed.
Manu Sporny: I would recommend we leave it open as a draft PR so that we keep referring to it
<mprorock> @orie - this is a draft PR - have some of the other PRs covered your comments?
... I think the AuthZ PRs that have been broken out of it already, and leaving it open keeps our options open if we add sections later that could also borrow from this
<orie> possibly... Im not against the idea behind his PR...
<orie> But it needs to graduate into a mergeable state.
Adrian Gropper: I'm glad to keep this open, and propose we not return to it until AuthZ sections have been substanciated a bit more
<orie> Justin is correct
<orie> we can't merge a draft.
Draft status is fine
<justin_richer> I marked it draft so it wouldn't be merged, it would be discussed.
<orie> draft is fine, I won't approve it until it is mergeable and feedback is addressed.
Manu Sporny: A label would be technically redundant but help scanning a long list of PRs
<justin_richer> I suggest "draft" because it has mechanical enforcement
<orie> ^ i think Justin did the right thin.
Mike Prorock: +1 Orie
<justin_richer> I don't care if you label it
<mahmoud> draft is fine
Draft is displayed in faint grey on the list by default
So it technically already displays it... just not in bright colors :D
<orie> its called "request changes"
<orie> ffs
Justin Richer: +1 To orie
I think repo admins can bump a PR from or to draft
<justin_richer> we can't
<justin_richer> ?
<mprorock> there is a do not merge label in there
Juan Caballero: +1
<brent> sorry for jumping queue
<justin_richer> labels don't block merge either
Ted Thibodeau: Yes you can merge with requested changes open, and yes, you can mark someone else's PR as draft
<orie> they do in the ccgg
... if you have admin rights
<orie> we just agreed to that...
<mprorock> there is a do not merge label
Ted Thibodeau: +1 Create label, apply it to this PR. it may be rarely used, but it's useful nonetheless.
<orie> you ccan mere over the do not merge label too
Mike Prorock: +1 Orie
Orie Steele: +1 Justin!
Manu Sporny: I think you can only mark draft on a PR from a fork
<mprorock> we need to trust the editors to read the comments for objections, changes requestd, etc
Justin Richer: I'm not a fan of "do not merge" because it can be used passive-aggressively
<brent> on github repos where I have proper access I can convert any PR to draft.
<tallted> draft theoretically means that its author doesn't think it's ready for others to review, it exits draft for others to review, and *then* the merge question comes up.
Orie Steele: These descriptive labels are kind of orthogonal to the behavior we're expecting in the code owners
... i think we need to remember the editors have power and responsibility
Manu Sporny: No op and move on?
<justin_richer> moving on is nice
Mike Prorock: +1 Justin

Topic: Pull Request 227 - Single Word Change

Manu Sporny: Good example of new policy, SHIP IT

Topic: Pull Request 228 - Intro to Authz Section

<justin_richer> as an aside, this group is absolutely killing itself with process, in my opinion
Orie Steele: +1 Justin.
Mike Prorock: +1 Justin
<orie> The same applies to this PR.
<orie> its been open for 10 days, no change requests
<orie> it should be merged immediatly
<orie> please merge it @manu.
<orie> they had 10 days to review it....
<orie> we just agreed to apply that policy.
Mahmoud Alkhraishi: +1 To Orie's point, assuming adrian's new CR's regarding the new name are accepted
Manu Sporny: Here is a good test case where I'm worried about the new policy being applied literally
<orie> just request changes if you want to block the PR... its trivial to do.
<orie> thanks Justin!
Justin Richer: Here is an editorial hackjob that takes the letter of my comment and not the spirit. I do not like this PR
<tallted> Multiple open change requests ... and says it's a partial substitute for #226, which also remains open, so what's the actual choice to be made?
Mike Prorock: Note: Joe has good editorial changes requested
Manu Sporny: That sounds like no objection to merge to me
Adrian Gropper: I think this reflects a particular API AuthZ strategy and I'd rather this PR stay open
<orie> there are no change requests, blocking the PR....
Ted Thibodeau: This opens with a confusing "Partial alternate to another open PR" disclaimer so it feels hedgey
<orie> use the "request for change feature"
... I think the 226 versus alternatives thing is hard to parse
Mike Prorock: But if 226 is in draft and it's intended as a reference, this isn't an alternative, it's an offshoot of!
<orie> I requested changes
<orie> now it can't be mergged
��

Topic: Pull Request 229 - Forbidden Authorization

<orie> I have requested changes on this PR.

Topic: Pull Request 230 - Authorization Delegation

<justin_richer> ZCAP and GNAP solve completely different problems, though ...
<orie> a normative statemen in a community draft...
Manu Sporny: Adrian does this make you happy or sad?
<orie> I suggest approving or requesting changes Adrian and Justin.
<orie> I don't care about your feelings, but would love to see a PR review on this ;)
<orie> ( I do care about your feelings )
Adrian Gropper: As I've said before, I am interested in consensus on ideological questions, not low-level spec language.
<orie> :)
Manu Sporny: I don't know how to help, we are working on spec language here. I keep trying to channel your comments as best I can in drafting these PRs
Orie Steele: +1 David
<orie> I will request changes
<juan_caballero> david_chadwick: i'm putting a comment in that should --> MAY because in some spec contexts, SHOULDs are interpreted as MUSTS
Ted Thibodeau: I strongly disagree, SHOULD means MUST UNLESS YOU KNOW WHAT YOU ARE DOING. MAY is way too open/loose
<orie> I agree with David, and I requested changes.
<orie> it now can't be merged.
Adrian Gropper: In contexts I've worked on, SHOULD has to be tested by conformance tests even if at deployment it isn't required
Adrian's comment on testing conforms with my understanding
<dmitri_zagidulin> orie: i'd be interested to know why (re should -> MAY), from you
<orie> I don't think anyone SHOULD use GNAP or ZCAPs ; )
<dmitri_zagidulin> thanks.

Topic: Pull Request 231 - OAuth 2.0 Bearer Tokens

Manu Sporny: I think these PRs parallelizes and compartmentalizes the options for AuthZ
<mprorock> can we accept Ted's changes and merge it?
Orie Steele: Manu could you accept Ted's changes and merge on the call now?
<orie> Thanks for the change request @TallTed!
Justin Richer: I think the language in this PR doesn't make sense to me, needs work
<orie> Justin, try using the "PR Review feature" of GitHub : )
Orie Steele: Try using less snark :) [scribe assist by Justin Richer]
<orie> I learned from the best
Manu Sporny: I think there is a new PR (233) that I'd love the group to review
<mprorock> this call was all snark
Thanks all

Meeting for 2019-12-17

Topics

  1. Introductions and Reintroductions
  2. Announcements and Reminders
  3. Action Items
  4. WebKMS

Meeting for 2019-12-10

Topics

  1. Agenda Review
  2. Introductions / Reintroductions
  3. Announcements and Reminders
  4. Progress & Action Items
  5. Verifiable Credentials for Education Task Force

Meeting for 2019-12-03

Topics

  1. Introductions and Reintroductions
  2. Announcements and Reminders
  3. Action Items
  4. did:key method

Meeting for 2019-11-12

Topics

  1. Introductions
  2. Announcements
  3. Action Items
  4. Personal Data Stores Comparison

Meeting for 2019-11-05

Topics

  1. Introductions and Reintroductions
  2. Announcements and Reminders
  3. Review action items and work items
  4. CCG 2020 Scope of work

Meeting for 2019-10-29

Topics

  1. Introductions / Re-Introductions
  2. Announcements
  3. Work Items and Action Items Review
  4. Year End Purge

Meeting for 2019-10-22

Topics

  1. Agenda review
  2. Announcements and Reminders
  3. Action Items
  4. Credential Schema Specification

Resolutions

  1. The W3C Credentials CG supports the rechartering of a Verifiable Credentials Maintenance Working Group.

Meeting for 2019-10-15

Topics

  1. Introductions and Reintroductions
  2. Announcements & Reminders
  3. Progress on Action Items
  4. DID handoff
  5. VC WG Maintenance Charter
  6. Contributing to JSON-LD Contexts

Meeting for 2019-10-08

Topics

  1. Introductions / Reintroductions
  2. Announcements & Reminders
  3. DIDs from a non-technical perspective
  4. IIW Report out

Meeting for 2019-09-10

Topics

  1. Introductions and Reintroduction
  2. Announcements & Reminders
  3. Action Items
  4. Verifiable Credentials next steps
  5. Decentralized Identity Working Group

Meeting for 2019-08-27

Topics

  1. Introductions and re-introductions
  2. DID working group charter / outreach
  3. Datashards
  4. Solid

Meeting for 2019-08-20

Topics

  1. Introductions and Reintroductions
  2. Announcements and Reminders
  3. Decentralized Topics at #RWOT9
  4. BTCR hackathon

Meeting for 2019-08-13

Topics

  1. Announcements and Reminders
  2. DID WG Charter and outreach
  3. Agents, Hubs, and More

Meeting for 2019-07-30

Topics

  1. intros and reintros
  2. announcements and reminders
  3. Progresson action items
  4. Standards setting process

Meeting for 2019-07-23

Meeting for 2019-07-09

Topics

  1. Introductions and Reintroductions
  2. Announcements and Reminders
  3. DID WG Charter Proposal
  4. Non-Violent Communication

Meeting for 2019-07-02

Topics

  1. Introductions and Reintroductions
  2. Announcements and Reminders
  3. Progress on Action Items
  4. Amira

Meeting for 2019-06-25

Topics

  1. Introductions and Re-introductions
  2. Accouncements
  3. Action Items
  4. Work Item Review, Fin

Meeting for 2019-06-18

Topics

  1. Introductions and Reintroductions
  2. Announcements and reminders
  3. Action Items
  4. Work item repair

Meeting for 2019-06-11

Topics

  1. Introductions and Re-introductions
  2. Announcements and Reminders
  3. Action Items
  4. Rubrics Task Force
  5. Credential CG Work Item Process Draft, simplified

Meeting for 2019-05-28

Topics

  1. Introductions and Reintroductions
  2. Announcements & Reminders
  3. Action Items
  4. Discuss New Work Item Process

Meeting for 2019-05-14

Topics

  1. Introductions and Reintroductions
  2. Announcements & Reminders
  3. Action Items
  4. Decentralized Identifier Rubrics

Meeting for 2019-05-07

Topics

  1. Introductions and Re-introductions
  2. Announcements
  3. Action Items
  4. Message from the chairs and ensuring a positive work environment
  5. IIW

Meeting for 2019-04-23

Topics

  1. Agenda review
  2. IP Note, call notes
  3. Introductions and re-introductions
  4. Announcements
  5. Open issues
  6. ABNF Task Force

Meeting for 2019-04-16

Topics

  1. Introductions / Reintroductions
  2. Annoucements and Reminders
  3. Action Items
  4. Survey Results

Meeting for 2019-04-02

Topics

  1. IP notes, call notes,
  2. Introductions & Reintroductions
  3. Announcements & Reminders
  4. Action Items
  5. DID Report out for AC Meeting
  6. Survey results

Meeting for 2019-03-26

Topics

  1. Introductions / Reintoroductions
  2. Announcements
  3. Progress on Action Items
  4. DIF Report Out

Meeting for 2019-03-19

Topics

  1. intros
  2. announcements and reminders
  3. Action items
  4. https DID method spec, and more

Meeting for 2019-03-12

Topics

  1. Introductions and Reintroductions
  2. Annoucements and reminders
  3. Action Items
  4. RWOT8 Report Out

Meeting for 2019-02-19

Topics

  1. Introductions/Reintroductions
  2. Announcements
  3. Action Items
  4. Review ABNF PR

Meeting for 2019-02-12

Topics

  1. Introductions
  2. announcements
  3. Action Items
  4. Use Cases

Meeting for 2019-02-05

Topics

  1. Introductions and Re-introductions
  2. Announcements and Reminders
  3. Work Item Review
  4. DID Issue Review

Meeting for 2019-01-29

Topics

  1. Introductions and Re-introductions
  2. Announcements and Reminders
  3. Action Items
  4. DID Pull Requests

Meeting for 2019-01-22

Topics

  1. Intros
  2. Announcements and reminders
  3. Progress on action items
  4. New work items
  5. Proposed work items
  6. DID Spec PR Triage

Meeting for 2019-01-15

Topics

  1. Introductions
  2. Announcements & Reminders
  3. Progress on Action Items
  4. Work Item Status Review
  5. New Work Items

Meeting for 2019-01-08

Topics

  1. Introductions and Re-introductions
  2. Announcements
  3. Action items
  4. Work items

Meeting for 2018-12-18

Topics

  1. Introductions
  2. Announcements and Reminders
  3. 2018 Year in Review

Meeting for 2018-12-04

Topics

  1. introductions
  2. reintroductions
  3. Announcements and Reminders
  4. DID resolver specification
  5. Work Items
  6. TAG charter review

Meeting for 2018-11-27

Topics

  1. Agenda Review
  2. Introductions / Reintroductions?
  3. Reminders and Events
  4. Progress on Current Action Items
  5. Work Items
  6. Review summary of previous DID stories, questions, painpoints meetings
  7. DID Summary High Points
  8. DID Explainer Template

Meeting for 2018-11-20

Topics

  1. Introductions and Reintroductions
  2. Announcements, reminders
  3. Action items
  4. Work Items
  5. Pain points

Meeting for 2018-11-13

Topics

  1. Introductions and Reintroductions
  2. Announcements
  3. Action Items
  4. Work Items
  5. DID Unique Selling Proposition

Meeting for 2018-11-06

Topics

  1. Introductions
  2. Update on Action Items
  3. Work Items
  4. W3C TPAC 2018
  5. IIW

Meeting for 2018-10-16

Topics

  1. Introductions and Reintroductions
  2. Announcements & Reminders
  3. Progress on Current Action Items
  4. Work Items
  5. TPAC Planning
  6. Feedback on charter

Meeting for 2018-10-09

Topics

  1. Agenda Review
  2. Introductions / Re-introductions
  3. Announcements / Reminders
  4. Progress on Action/Work Items
  5. W3C TPAC Planning.

Meeting for 2018-10-02

Topics

  1. Introductions and Reintroductions
  2. Announcements
  3. Review Action Items
  4. Work Items
  5. New Business
  6. RWoT7

Meeting for 2018-09-18

Topics

  1. Introductions & Reintroductions
  2. Announcements & Reminders
  3. Progress on Current Action Items
  4. Status of work items

Meeting for 2018-08-21

Meeting for 2018-08-14

Topics

  1. introductions and re-introductions
  2. announcements and reminders
  3. Progress on Current Action Items
  4. Progress on current action items
  5. Work items
  6. Jolocom

Meeting for 2018-08-07

Topics

  1. Introductions
  2. Review announcements
  3. Action items
  4. Work Items
  5. proof of personhood

Meeting for 2018-07-24

Topics

  1. Introductions
  2. Agenda Review
  3. Announcements & Reminders
  4. Progress on Current Action Items
  5. Work Items
  6. Amira Use Case

Meeting for 2018-07-17

Topics

  1. Agenda Review and Introductions
  2. Roadmap
  3. DID WG Charter

Meeting for 2018-07-10

Topics

  1. Introductions
  2. Announcements and Reminders
  3. uPort Ethereum DID Method

Meeting for 2018-07-03

Topics

  1. Introductions and Reintroductions
  2. Transparency
  3. Announcements and Reminders
  4. Action Items
  5. Work Items
  6. Focal Use Cases
  7. DID-Auth

Meeting for 2018-06-26

Topics

  1. Introductions
  2. Agenda Review
  3. Announcements & Reminders
  4. Progress on Current Action Items
  5. Work Items
  6. Focal Use Cases for DID WG
  7. Muscians and Influencers

Meeting for 2018-06-19

Topics

  1. Introductions and Reintroductions
  2. Announcements and Reminders
  3. Action Items
  4. Work Items
  5. Requirements for DIDs

Meeting for 2018-06-12

Topics

  1. Agenda review
  2. Introductions
  3. Announcements
  4. Action items - https://github.com/w3c-ccg/community/issues?q=is%3Aissue+is%3Aopen+label%3A%22action+item%22_
  5. Work items
  6. DID Method Requirements?
  7. Focal use cases

Meeting for 2018-06-05

Topics

  1. Introductions
  2. Announcements and Reminders
  3. Progress on current action items
  4. Status of Work Items
  5. Focal Use Cases for DID WG

Meeting for 2018-05-29

Topics

  1. Introductions and Re-Introductions
  2. Wyoming Blockchain Task Force Meeting
  3. Summer Hackathon
  4. Focal Use Cases

Meeting for 2018-05-22

Topics

  1. Introductions/Re-introductions
  2. Announcements and Reminders
  3. Action Items
  4. Work Items
  5. Update on Educational Task Force
  6. Formation of a User Story Task Force

Meeting for 2018-05-15

Topics

  1. Introductions and Reintroductions
  2. Reminders
  3. Progress on Current Action Items
  4. Status of Work Items
  5. Call for DID Focal Use Cases
  6. DID issues working session
  7. DID service naming and identification
  8. DID Document versioning
  9. Extensibility

Meeting for 2018-05-08

Topics

  1. introductions
  2. action items update
  3. work items
  4. digital verification github items
  5. Digital Verification community items and CCG people
  6. DID Use Cases & Domains

Meeting for 2018-05-01

Topics

  1. Reintroductions
  2. Action Items
  3. DID Working Group Transition

Meeting for 2018-04-24

Topics

  1. CCG Process

Meeting for 2018-04-19

Topics

  1. poll results
  2. Peer claims https://hackmd.io/BYWqUeNDRimyKJL5xsSOiw

Meeting for 2018-04-17

Topics

  1. Introductions
  2. Announcements
  3. Issues List
  4. ZK Lang

Meeting for 2018-04-10

Topics

  1. Introductions
  2. Next Week - Crypto Tuesdays - ZKLang
  3. Action Items
  4. MyData Panel at Helsinki
  5. Work items - DID Spec and DID Methods
  6. IIW26 Report Out
  7. Verifiable Claims WG Meeting

Meeting for 2018-04-05

Topics

  1. Occupational and Educational Credentials

Meeting for 2018-03-27

Topics

  1. Introductions / ReIntroductions
  2. Education Credentials Task Force
  3. https://github.com/w3c-ccg/community
  4. DID Auth Follow-up

Meeting for 2018-03-22

Topics

  1. Occupational/Educational Task Force

Meeting for 2018-03-20

Topics

  1. Introductions
  2. Announcements
  3. Current action items progress
  4. Work items
  5. DID-based Authentication (DID-Auth)

Meeting for 2018-03-13

Topics

  1. Introductions
  2. Announcements
  3. Report from Rebooting the Web of Trust 6

Meeting for 2018-02-15

Topics

  1. DID Service URLs
  2. Other DID Spec Items

Meeting for 2018-02-13

Topics

  1. Announcements
  2. DID Authentication
  3. Object Capabilities

Resolutions

  1. Create an Education and Occupational Credentials Task Force as described in https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-credentials/2018Feb/0013.html
  2. Adopt the Linked Data Object Capabilities specification as a work item.

Meeting for 2018-02-06

Topics

  1. Introductions
  2. Announcements
  3. DID Specification Reconciliation
  4. Crypto Tuesdays
  5. Cryptography Suite Implementations

Meeting for 2018-01-30

Topics

  1. Introductions and Reintroductions
  2. Agenda for Today
  3. Action Items
  4. CG Process
  5. Data Minimization
  6. Education Task Force

Resolutions

  1. Merge PR 41 into the main specification based on no objections, we have achieved consensus on this PR.

Meeting for 2018-01-25

Topics

  1. DID Harmonization PR
  2. Encryption
  3. DID Fragment Identifiers

Meeting for 2018-01-23

Topics

  1. Introduction to Akila
  2. Announcements, Focus for 2018
  3. DID Harmonization
  4. DID Hackathon Outcomes

Meeting for 2018-01-16

Topics

  1. Reintroductions
  2. Announcements
  3. Work Items
  4. Outreach
  5. Work Breakdown Structure (WBS) aka Roadmap Review

Meeting for 2018-01-11

Topics

  1. DID Harmonization
  2. Spec Updates

Meeting for 2018-01-09

Topics

  1. Reintroduction for Kerri Lemoie
  2. Announcements
  3. Progress on current action items
  4. DID Harmonization Proposal #1
  5. Outreach

Meeting for 2018-01-04

Topics

  1. Biometric Authentication
  2. DID Spec Scope?
  3. DID Document Extensibility
  4. Fundamental DID Architecture

Meeting for 2017-12-21

Topics

  1. Cryptographic Key Material

Meeting for 2017-12-19

Topics

  1. Introductions and Reintroductions
  2. Announcements and Status Updates
  3. 2017 Year in Review

Meeting for 2017-12-14

Topics

  1. Current Status of DID Hardening Discussions
  2. Options for Keys / Authentication
  3. Option #D

Resolutions

  1. Eliminate Option #3 from the discussion choices as described in this email: https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-credentials/2017Dec/0046.html

Meeting for 2017-12-12

Topics

  1. Introductions / Reintroductions
  2. Announcements
  3. Status of Work Items
  4. engagement model
  5. browser api and polyfill
  6. privacy and security requirements
  7. DID Spec Change Requests
  8. Other Topics

Meeting for 2017-12-07

Topics

  1. Intellectual Property Release
  2. Two Stages of DID Document
  3. Simple Arrays of Key Descriptions

Meeting for 2017-12-05

Topics

  1. Agenda Review
  2. Announcements
  3. Introductions
  4. W3C CCG Process Document
  5. W3C Intellectual Property Requirements & our CG Process
  6. CCG Registries

Meeting for 2017-11-30

Topics

  1. DID Hardening Proposal v3
  2. Format Independence
  3. Optional ID Property for the DID

Meeting for 2017-11-14

Topics

  1. Introduction to Mark Miller (Google)
  2. DID Spec Review
  3. Capabilities in Verifiable Credentials
  4. W3C TPAC 2017 Update

Meeting for 2017-10-31

Topics

  1. Status of Action Items
  2. Credential Handler API
  3. W3C TPAC Planning
  4. Post RWoT DID Spec

Meeting for 2017-10-24

Topics

  1. Reintroductions
  2. W3C TPAC
  3. DID Specification
  4. Digital Verification Cryptography
  5. JSON-LD and LD Signature Updates
  6. Credential Handler API
  7. Lifecycle Model
  8. Verifiable News
  9. Other Work Items
  10. Path for DID Spec Standardization

Meeting for 2017-10-17

Topics

  1. Introductions and Reintroductions
  2. New DID Spec PR
  3. Verifiable News
  4. W3C TPAC Planning

Meeting for 2017-09-26

Topics

  1. Introductions
  2. Action Items
  3. Credential Handler Polyfill Video
  4. Data Minimization & Selective Disclosure
  5. DID Specification
  6. Next week

Meeting for 2017-09-19

Topics

  1. Introductions and Reintroductions
  2. Proposed changes to DID Spec Overview
  3. DID Spec Discussion

Meeting for 2017-09-12

Topics

  1. Introductions and Reintroductions
  2. Action Items
  3. Proofs vs. Signatures
  4. Capabilities-based Security Model

Meeting for 2017-09-05

Topics

  1. Agenda Review
  2. Introductions / Re-introductions
  3. Action Item Review
  4. ActivityPub and Mastadon
  5. DID Specification

Meeting for 2017-08-29

Topics

  1. Introductions
  2. Work Item Progress
  3. Privacy and Security Requirements
  4. DID Specification Progress

Meeting for 2017-08-22

Topics

  1. Administrivia - Dialing In
  2. Introductions
  3. Mission Statement Review
  4. Credential Handler API (and polyfill)

Meeting for 2017-08-15

Topics

  1. Introductions
  2. Fake News and Bots
  3. Mission Statement
  4. Administrative Items

Meeting for 2017-08-08

Topics

  1. Introductions and Reintroductions
  2. Agenda Review
  3. Mission Statement

Meeting for 2017-08-01

Topics

  1. Action Items
  2. Introductions and Re-introductions
  3. Update on Community Group Name
  4. Revising the Mission Statement

Meeting for 2017-07-25

Topics

  1. Re-Introductions
  2. Action Items
  3. DID Specification Work Item
  4. Lifecycle Deep Dive

Resolutions

  1. Accept the DID Specification as a Credentials CG work item.

Meeting for 2017-07-18

Topics

  1. Introduction to Lionel Walberger
  2. Action Items
  3. DID Specification update
  4. Cryptography for Anonymous Credentials

Meeting for 2017-06-27

Topics

  1. Introductions
  2. Selective Disclosure and CL Signatures

Meeting for 2017-06-20

Topics

  1. Bitcoin DID Method (BTCR)
  2. Chainpoint v3.0
  3. Linked Data Signatures

Meeting for 2017-06-13

Topics

  1. Introductions
  2. Action Items
  3. Community Group Naming
  4. Interaction with Banking/Finance Industry
  5. Planning for W3C TPAC
  6. Work Item Review
  7. RDF Dataset Canonicalization
  8. Privacy and Security Requirements

Meeting for 2017-06-06

Topics

  1. Introductions
  2. Agenda Review
  3. Action Items
  4. Current Polls
  5. Decentralized Identifiers
  6. Reputation Systems
  7. Next Meeting

Meeting for 2017-05-30

Topics

  1. Community Group Scope and Naming
  2. Verifiable Claims Browser API and Browser Polyfill
  3. Lifecycle of a Verifiable Claim
  4. Data Minimization and Selective Disclosure Report
  5. Decentralized Identifier Spec

Meeting for 2017-05-23

Topics

  1. Introductions
  2. Action Item Review
  3. Future Work Items Discussion

Meeting for 2017-05-16

Topics

  1. Introduce New Chairs
  2. New Members
  3. Review of Credentails CG Mission Statement
  4. Community Group Priorities
  5. Potential Work Items

Meeting for 2017-05-09

Topics

  1. Agenda Review and Introductions
  2. WG Document Handoff
  3. Joining the VCWG
  4. Reminder: this is last CG call at this time
  5. Open Mic / Community Group Next Steps
  6. CG and WG call next week

Meeting for 2017-05-02

Topics

  1. Finalize CG Reports, hand-off to WG
  2. Trip Reports
  3. Working Group Membership
  4. Suggestions for next week

Resolutions

  1. Publish 2017-05-01 drafts as Final Reports. Gather feedback until this coming Friday, and publish final specifications if no objections.

Meeting for 2017-03-14

Topics

  1. Agenda review and Introductions
  2. Status of Verifiable Claims WG Creation
  3. No meeting on 3/28 (reminder)
  4. DO_NOT_CORRELATE flag discussion
  5. WoT use case
  6. Action Item Review (https://goo.gl/V4XTBT)
  7. Suggestions for next week agenda

Meeting for 2017-03-07

Topics

  1. Status of VCWG Creation
  2. Meeting for 2017-03-28 Cancelled
  3. IMS Badge Summit Update
  4. RWoT Demo Status
  5. Prioritizing Pull Requests
  6. Actions Item Review
  7. amigus email re: privacy: https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-credentials/2017Mar/0002.html
  8. Suggestions for Next Meeting Agenda

Meeting for 2017-02-28

Topics

  1. Introduction to Kim Duffy from BlockCerts
  2. Status of Verifiable Claims WG Creation
  3. Update on Verifiable Claims Playground
  4. Action Item Review
  5. Agenda for Next Week

Meeting for 2017-02-21

Topics

  1. Introduction to Sean Bohan
  2. Status of WG Creation
  3. Action Item Review
  4. Face to Face Meetings
  5. Requirements
  6. Correlatability of Usage Patterns
  7. Primary or Secondary Subject

Meeting for 2017-02-14

Topics

  1. Introduction to Abbas Ali from R3
  2. Status of Verifiable Claims WG Creation
  3. Sandbox for the implementers to work on
  4. Action Item Review
  5. Face to Face Meeting Opportunities
  6. Portable Reputation Kit

Meeting for 2017-02-07

Topics

  1. Agenda Review and Introductions
  2. Status of Verifiable Claims WG Creation
  3. Status of Face to Face in March
  4. Action Item Review
  5. Discuss work on requirements gathering
  6. Use Case Issue 18: Holder Terminology
  7. Use Case Issue 34: Lifecycle Engagement - next steps

Resolutions

  1. Do not close yet Issue 18 yet.

Meeting for 2017-01-31

Topics

  1. Agenda Review and Introductions
  2. Status of Verifiable Claims WG creation
  3. Possible VCWG F2F week of March 21st 2017
  4. Use Cases Framework Discussion

Meeting for 2017-01-24

Topics

  1. Agenda Review
  2. Status of Verifiable Claims WG Vote
  3. Use Cases Narratives and Revocation/Privacy
  4. Correlation Analysis and Prevention
  5. Filtering, Focusing use cases

Meeting for 2017-01-17

Topics

  1. Agenda review and Introductions
  2. Status of Verifiable Claims WG Vote
  3. Web of Trust Use Case
  4. Prioritization of/response to privacy concerns

Meeting for 2017-01-10

Topics

  1. Vote for Verifiable Claims WG
  2. Use Cases Document Update
  3. Agenda Items for Next Week

Meeting for 2016-12-20

Topics

  1. Introduction to Pari, from Intuit
  2. Agenda Review
  3. Verifiable Claims WG Vote
  4. Discussion on Github
  5. Intro to Github Pull Requests
  6. Use of WebIDL in the Spec

Meeting for 2016-12-13

Topics

  1. Vote for Verifiable Claims WG is Open
  2. Reference Libraries
  3. Use of JSON/JSON-LD in spec
  4. Next Meeting

Meeting for 2016-12-06

Topics

  1. Introduction to John Koshy
  2. Rebooting Web of Trust, Paris
  3. Issue Prioritization
  4. Use of JSON/JSON-LD in spec

Meeting for 2016-11-29

Topics

  1. Agenda review
  2. New Participants
  3. New Location for Specs
  4. Status of W3M Charter Review
  5. Call for review
  6. Brief review of adding issues in GitHub
  7. Nesting Signatures with JWT

Meeting for 2016-11-15

Topics

  1. W3C AB Feedback
  2. Specific Use Cases
  3. Age Verification Use Case
  4. Spec Issues

Meeting for 2016-11-08

Topics

  1. Gathering More Use Case Data

Meeting for 2016-11-01

Topics

  1. Rebooting Web of Trust
  2. Internet Identity Workshop #23
  3. Verifiable Claims Face-to-Face
  4. Intro to Phil Archer from W3C
  5. Responses to VC Concerns

Meeting for 2016-10-28

Topics

  1. Agenda Review
  2. Long-term Architectural Concerns
  3. Decentralized Identifiers
  4. Start of Data Model Deep Dive
  5. Data Model Deep Dive
  6. Digital Signatures
  7. Responding to Charter Review Comments

Meeting for 2016-10-27

Topics

  1. Welcome and Administrivia
  2. Introduction to Use Cases
  3. Good Use Cases
  4. Education Industry Use Cases
  5. Healthcare Use Cases
  6. Payments Use Cases
  7. Verifiable Claims Proposed Architecture / Goals
  8. Data model and Representation Overview
  9. The W3C Process
  10. VCF2F Day Two Agenda Bash

Meeting for 2016-10-11

Topics

  1. Verifiable Claims Face-to-Face Agenda
  2. architecture (shane)
  3. data model, representations (manu) - day 1 will feel repetitive b/c there will be ~50% newcomers

Meeting for 2016-10-04

Topics

  1. After Action Report - W3C TPAC
  2. Registering for VC Face-to-Face
  3. Verifiable Claims Face-to-Face Agenda
  4. Feedback on W3C Verifiable Claims Announcement

Meeting for 2016-09-06

Topics

  1. Quick introduction from Pindar Wong
  2. F2F Meeting at IIW
  3. Verifiable Claims Implementations to Demo
  4. Verifiable Claims RC-2 Draft Charter Feedback
  5. Estonian E-Residency Face-to-Face
  6. Planning for W3C TPAC
  7. Interplanetary File System and Verifiable Claims

Meeting for 2016-08-16

Topics

  1. Introduction to Bob Burke, Koupon Media
  2. Introduction to Adrian Gropper, HealthURL
  3. Verifiable Claims Face-to-Face at IIW
  4. Verifiable Claims RC-2 Draft Charter
  5. IPFS and Verifiable Claims

Meeting for 2016-08-02

Topics

  1. Feedback on Charter from W3C Management
  2. Verifiable Claims Face-to-Face Agenda
  3. Terminology and Expiration
  4. Linked Data Encrypted Signatures

Meeting for 2016-07-19

Topics

  1. Review All Dissenting Opinions
  2. JOSE / JWT Clarification/Analysis
  3. Verifiable Claims Face-to-Face Agenda
  4. Coordinating with Other Workshops

Meeting for 2016-07-12

Topics

  1. Verifiable Claims Presentation at WPIG face-to-face
  2. Identified Verifiable Claims "Weak Points"
  3. Next Steps

Meeting for 2016-06-21

Topics

  1. Verifiable Claims Working Group Proposal
  2. Terminology Results
  3. Data Model Specification
  4. Use Cases
  5. Next Steps

Meeting for 2016-06-14

Topics

  1. Terminology Poll
  2. Implementer Commitment Summary
  3. Verifiable Claims Architecture
  4. Primer
  5. Data Model Specification
  6. Use Cases
  7. Items that are "Good Enough" for Review

Meeting for 2016-06-08

Topics

  1. Discuss purpose of architecture proposal
  2. Analysis of current document
  3. Identifier registry
  4. Repository
  5. Simplifying Diagram

Meeting for 2016-06-07

Topics

  1. VCTF Deliverables
  2. Verifiable Claims Use Cases Review
  3. Verifiable Claims Charter
  4. Verifiable Claims Charter FAQ
  5. Architecture Summary
  6. Verifiable Claims Data Model Specification
  7. Terminology Conflicts
  8. Other items

Resolutions

  1. Adopt self-sovereign terminology over user-centric terminology.

Meeting for 2016-05-31

Topics

  1. Introduction to New Participants
  2. Self-Sovereign Identity Architecture
  3. Decentralized Identifiers
  4. Verifiable Claims Use Cases Review
  5. Update on Work Items

Meeting for 2016-05-24

Topics

  1. Introductions to New Participants
  2. Agenda Bashing
  3. Introduction to Anil John and DHS Blockchain R&D
  4. Other Introductions
  5. United Nations ID2020 Summit Recap
  6. Rebooting Web of Trust Design Workshop Recap
  7. Recent Vermont Legal Finding
  8. Update on Work Items

Meeting for 2016-05-17

Topics

  1. Introduction to Alka Gupta from GlobalID
  2. Blockchain and Identity
  3. Verifiable Claims Data Model Specification
  4. Credentials Transparency Initiative Terminology
  5. Target Date Web Payments IG Hand-off

Resolutions

  1. Augment the "Credential" terminology in the specification with a modifier like "OpenCredential" or "IdentityCredential" or "VerifiableCredential".

Meeting for 2016-05-10

Topics

  1. Introduction to Alok from Cambridge Blockchain
  2. Review of Survey Status
  3. Work on Existing Docs
  4. Verifiable Claims Data Model Specification
  5. Survey Results/Overview
  6. One page W3C AC Rep Summary
  7. Architecture Summary
  8. Implementers Summary

Meeting for 2016-04-26

Topics

  1. Credentials Transparency Initiative Alignment
  2. Review of Questionnaire Status
  3. Verifiable Claims Data Model Specification
  4. One page W3C AC Rep Summary
  5. Charter Cleanup
  6. Use Case Reviews

Meeting for 2016-04-19

Topics

  1. Introductions to New Participants
  2. United Nations ID2020 Initiative
  3. Review of Questionnaire Responses
  4. Work Items

Meeting for 2016-04-05

Topics

  1. Introduction to Christopher Allen
  2. Blockchain Interest in Identity Credentials
  3. Review of Questionnaire
  4. Charter Review To Date
  5. Options Moving Forward

Meeting for 2016-03-29

Topics

  1. Introduction to Todd Albers
  2. W3C Advisory Committee Summary
  3. Next Steps (in the next 4-6 weeks)
  4. Spec Ops

Meeting for 2016-03-15

Topics

  1. Draft Charter Proposal
  2. Use Cases Document
  3. Card for AC Meeting
  4. Vocabulary changes - Issuer, Curator, Inspector

Resolutions

  1. Integrate as much feedback as possible before 3pm today and send the editor's draft charter and use cases out for informal review to the interviewees, the survey respondents, and the W3C Advisory Committee.

Meeting for 2016-03-08

Topics

  1. Draft Charter Proposal
  2. Material for W3C Advisory Committe Meeting at MIT
  3. Use Cases Document
  4. Expected Timeline for VCTF Charter Review

Meeting for 2016-03-01

Topics

  1. Review Web Payments IG Vote on VCTF
  2. Next Steps (W3C AC Meeting)
  3. Draft Charter Proposal
  4. Use Cases Document

Meeting for 2016-02-19

Topics

  1. Current Status
  2. Use Cases Document
  3. Verifiable Claims Task Force Presentation
  4. Verifiable Claims Task Force Final Report
  5. Draft Charter Proposal

Meeting for 2016-02-12

Topics

  1. Background on Jeanne, Bob, and the Credentials Transparency Initiative
  2. Problem Statement
  3. Data Format
  4. Technical Advisory Committee on Metadata
  5. Need for Credentials Technology

Meeting for 2016-02-09

Topics

  1. Plan to Finishing up Interviews
  2. Verifiable Claims Task Force Final Report
  3. Use Cases Document
  4. Draft Charter Proposal

Meeting for 2016-02-02

Topics

  1. Summary of Interviews So Far
  2. Documents Needed By Web Payments Face-to-Face
  3. Verifiable Claims Task Force Final Report
  4. Use Cases Document
  5. Draft Charter Proposal

Meeting for 2016-01-29-2

Topics

  1. Introduction
  2. Problem Statement
  3. Level of assurance, Level of protection, and Level of control
  4. The Problem with User-Centric
  5. Important Trust Models
  6. OpenID, SAML, and Privacy
  7. Potential Standardization Opportunities
  8. Best Place for Standardization Work

Meeting for 2016-01-29-1

Topics

  1. Problem Statement
  2. User-centric Design vs Privacy-centric Design
  3. OpenID Connect, SAML, and OAuth
  4. Useful Technology Pieces
  5. The Work on OpenID
  6. The Best Mode for a Solution

Meeting for 2016-01-28

Topics

  1. Problem Statement
  2. Stakeholders and Benefits
  3. SAML, Oauth, OpenID Connect, and JOSE
  4. Important Work Items
  5. Best Location for Standards Work

Meeting for 2016-01-27

Topics

  1. Problem Statement
  2. OpenID Connect
  3. Definitions and User-Centric vs. Service-Centric
  4. Respect Network
  5. Portable Identifiers
  6. Ideal Place for Work

Meeting for 2016-01-26

Topics

  1. Interview Narratives So Far
  2. Responding to Identified Narratives
  3. Draft Charter Proposal
  4. Use Cases Document

Meeting for 2016-01-19

Topics

  1. Update on Past and Upcoming Interviews
  2. Plan (or lack thereof) for Face-to-Face in February
  3. Stalled Work

Meeting for 2016-01-08

Topics

  1. Verifiable Claims Problem Statement
  2. Anti-Fraud / Anti-Abuse
  3. Revocation / Status Checking
  4. Slow Evolution of Agent-Centric Protocols
  5. Trust and Semantics

Meeting for 2016-01-05

Topics

  1. Background on Verifiable Claims work
  2. Problem Statement and Scope
  3. Key Questions
  4. The Interviews

Meeting for 2015-12-15

Topics

  1. Introduction of New Participants
  2. Review Deliverables
  3. Review Milestones / Timelines
  4. Review Benefits for Stakeholders

Resolutions

  1. Request that the Web Payments Interest Group approve the Verifiable Claims Task Force with the caveat that we still need to do interviews before finalizing work and problem statement.
  2. Adopt the Deliverables in the VCTF wiki as they stand today.
  3. Adopt the Milestones / Timeline as it stands today in the wiki.
  4. Adopt the benefits as they stand now in the wiki with the understanding that we may come back and revise the list as we learn more over the next couple of months.

Meeting for 2015-12-08

Topics

  1. Introductions to New Participants
  2. Review of Scope
  3. Review Stakeholders
  4. Review Task Force Operation
  5. Review Success Criteria
  6. Next Steps

Resolutions

  1. Adopt the Scope statement as it exists in the Task Force Proposal wiki.
  2. Adopt the Stakeholders section as it stands in the wiki.
  3. Adopt the Task Force Operation section as it stands in the wiki.
  4. Adopt the success criteria as it stands in the wiki.

Meeting for 2015-12-01

Topics

  1. Introduction of Participants
  2. Review the purpose of the call
  3. Review Goals
  4. Review Weekly Meetings
  5. Review Definitions
  6. Review Problem Statement

Resolutions

  1. Adopt the goals statement as it exists in the Verifiable Claims Task Force Proposal.
  2. Adopt the weekly telecon format, tools, and time listed here http://w3c.github.io/vctf/#telecons with fixes to the URLs pointed out by Dave Longley.
  3. There is a significant difference between user-centric and service-centric architectures when it comes to verifiable claims.
  4. Adopt the definitions as they stand in the Verifiable Claims Task Force Proposal.
  5. Adopt the Problem Statement in the Verifiable Claims Task Force Proposal with the changes made during the call today.

Meeting for 2015-11-24

Topics

  1. Introduction to Dan Burnett
  2. WPIG / Verifiable Claims After Action Review
  3. Goals for Next Week's Meeting
  4. Administrivia for Next Week's Meeting

Meeting for 2015-11-17

Topics

  1. Current Status of Task Force Proposal
  2. Focus on Use Cases
  3. ToDo Items

Meeting for 2015-11-10

Topics

  1. Credentials Task Force in WPIG Update
  2. Tasks for Credentials CG
  3. Linked Data Fast Track WG Update

Meeting for 2015-11-03

Topics

  1. Introductions to New Participants
  2. Work Generated as a Result of W3C TPAC
  3. WebDHT Spec Released
  4. Reorganizing this group around new Task Force

Meeting for 2015-10-20

Topics

  1. W3C TPAC Credentials Presentation
  2. Introduction to Rebecca Simmons
  3. Introduction to Deb Everhart
  4. Linked Data Signatures Update
  5. HTTP Signatures Update

Meeting for 2015-10-13

Topics

  1. NACS Show
  2. HTTP Signatures
  3. Introductions to New Members
  4. W3C TPAC Credentials DRAFT Presentation
  5. Credentials Reference Implementation Demo
  6. Post-meeting Discussion

Meeting for 2015-10-06

Topics

  1. Current state of Credentials Survey
  2. Survey Outreach
  3. Upcoming Demos
  4. Lumina Meeting Review

Meeting for 2015-08-25

Topics

  1. Recruiting
  2. Standards Implementation Foundation
  3. Update from IMS Global
  4. Capabilities Wrap-up

Meeting for 2015-08-18

Topics

  1. Recruiting
  2. IMS Global Update
  3. Capabilities Document

Meeting for 2015-08-11

Topics

  1. Introduction to Annie Jenssen
  2. Recruiting
  3. Roadmap
  4. Credentialing Capabilities and Current Proposal

Meeting for 2015-08-04

Topics

  1. Recruiting
  2. Glossary Document
  3. Vision document

Meeting for 2015-07-28

Topics

  1. Recruiting
  2. Glossary Document
  3. Vision Document

Meeting for 2015-07-21

Topics

  1. Introduction to Andrew
  2. Introduction to John Tibbetts
  3. Recruiting
  4. Vision
  5. Glossary
  6. Use Cases
  7. Capabilities
  8. Roadmap

Meeting for 2015-07-14

Topics

  1. Introduction to Brendan Benshoof
  2. Recruiting
  3. Producing Documents
  4. Vision document
  5. Use Cases
  6. Capabilities
  7. Roadmap

Meeting for 2015-07-07

Topics

  1. Recruiting
  2. authorization.io
  3. Decentralized Identifiers

Meeting for 2015-06-30

Topics

  1. Credentials WG Plan
  2. Introductions of New Members
  3. Recruiting

Meeting for 2015-06-23

Topics

  1. Web Payments IG face-to-face in NYC
  2. Introduction to Matt Stone
  3. Current Status of Credentials at W3C
  4. Badge Alliance updates
  5. Focus on Recruiting New Members

Meeting for 2015-06-09

Topics

  1. Web Payments IG and Credentials

Meeting for 2015-06-02

Topics

  1. Credentials WG Charter and WPIG
  2. Recruiting document
  3. Credential Management API update
  4. Use Cases

Meeting for 2015-05-26

Topics

  1. Recruiting document (non-W3C member)
  2. Introduction to James and Arto
  3. Graph Normalization Update
  4. Recruiting W3C Members
  5. Credential Management API Extension (update)
  6. Use Cases

Meeting for 2015-05-19

Topics

  1. Introduction to Jordan Windsor
  2. Open Badges xsd:string issue
  3. WebAppSec Credential Management API
  4. Graph Normalization Test Suite
  5. Community Group Focus

Meeting for 2015-05-12

Topics

  1. Recap of 2015 Groningen Declaration Meeting
  2. OBI JSON-LD Context
  3. RDF Graph Normalization
  4. Credentials WG Charter on Web Payments Agenda
  5. Credentials WG support questionnaire
  6. Recruiting co-chair from Pearson

Meeting for 2015-05-05

Topics

  1. Introduction to Richard Varn
  2. Open Badges 1.1 Release
  3. 2015 Groningen Declaration Meeting
  4. WebAppSec Credential Management API Status Update
  5. Level One Project
  6. Credentials WG Charter on Web Payments Agenda
  7. Next Steps

Meeting for 2015-04-14

Topics

  1. Use Cases
  2. WebAppSec Credential Management API
  3. Credentials/Badges Vocabulary Update

Resolutions

  1. Switch the primary use cases document over to the micro-use cases approach, concentrate all future use case work into that document.

Meeting for 2015-04-07

Topics

  1. Executive Summary
  2. Use Cases
  3. Credentials/Badges Vocabulary Update

Meeting for 2015-03-31

Topics

  1. W3C Interest in Credentials WG
  2. Executive Summary
  3. Use Cases
  4. Credentials/Badges Vocabulary Update
  5. Roadmap

Meeting for 2015-03-10

Topics

  1. Teleconference Bridge
  2. Credentials Working Group Charter
  3. Use Cases / Linked Data Signatures
  4. Credentials/Badges Vocabulary Update
  5. Roadmap Update

Meeting for 2015-03-03

Topics

  1. Credentials Working Group Charter
  2. Use Cases
  3. Profile Use Cases
  4. Linked Data Signatures spec
  5. Credentials/Badges Vocabulary Update

Meeting for 2015-02-10

Topics

  1. Introduction to Laura Fowler
  2. Introduction to Brent Shambaugh
  3. Web Payments IG Face-to-Face
  4. Decentralized Identifiers for Credentials/Badges
  5. Signatures Update
  6. Badge Alliance Context/Vocabulary Update
  7. Roadmap Update

Meeting for 2015-01-27

Topics

  1. Signatures Update
  2. Badges/Credentials Vocabulary and Context
  3. Digital Promise Summit for Workforce

Meeting for 2015-01-20

Topics

  1. Bedrock / P3 Release
  2. Credentials / Web Payments IG Agenda
  3. Signatures Update
  4. Badge Alliance Vocabulary/Context Update
  5. Roadmap

Meeting for 2015-01-13

Topics

  1. Web Payments Face-to-Face
  2. Linked Data Signatures
  3. JSON-LD Credentials Context/Vocabulary Update
  4. Roadmap Update

Meeting for 2014-12-09

Topics

  1. Introduction to elf Pavlik
  2. Signatures Update
  3. Context Work Stream Update
  4. Roadmap Work Stream update
  5. Hosted vs. Signed

Meeting for 2014-12-02

Topics

  1. Coordination Plan for Next Few Months
  2. Path Forward for Digital Signatures
  3. Moving CG Documents onto REC-track at W3C

Meeting for 2014-11-25

Topics

  1. Digital Signatures - Pushback from Social Web / Harry Halpin
  2. Introduction to Dale McCrory
  3. Digital Signature Strategy

Meeting for 2014-11-18

Topics

  1. Groningen Declaration
  2. Digital Signatures for Credentials

Meeting for 2014-11-11

Topics

  1. Review W3C TPAC Meeting
  2. Web Payments IG Meeting
  3. W3C TPAC Credentials Hallway Discussions
  4. Planning for next 2 months

Meeting for 2014-10-28

Topics

  1. Introduction
  2. Identity Proofing
  3. Scope of CG Work
  4. Use Cases / Future Work
  5. Identifier Portability
  6. Data Rights, Legacy Support

Meeting for 2014-10-21

Topics

  1. Intro from Dale McCrory from Courseload
  2. Introduction to Nate Otto from Concentric Sky
  3. Review Credentials CG Presentation to Web Payments IG
  4. Review Credentials CG F2F Agenda
  5. Review Credentials Use Cases vote status
  6. Open Badges and JSON-LD

Meeting for 2014-10-14

Topics

  1. W3C TPAC and Credentials CG
  2. Credentials CG Use Cases Review
  3. Start Discussing Roadmap Document

Resolutions

  1. Publish a preliminary Credentials Use Cases document and vote on publishing it as a first public working draft before W3C TPAC. Start the vote at 5pm ET on Tuesday October 14th 2014 and keep it open for 7 days.

Meeting for 2014-10-07

Topics

  1. Voting Process on Credentials Use Case Document
  2. Web Payments Agenda on CG call last week
  3. Comments on Use Cases Document
  4. Remaining Use Cases
  5. Verifiable Claims
  6. Media Rights
  7. Data Rights
  8. Proof of Pseudo-anonymity
  9. Data Rights Agreement Before Transmission of Data
  10. Access Revocation
  11. Access Audit
  12. Access Credential Audit Information
  13. Education Use Cases
  14. Access to Transcripts
  15. Online Transcript
  16. Continuing Education
  17. University Credits
  18. Bachelor's Degree
  19. Any other use cases?

Resolutions

  1. Create and publish a preliminary Credentials Use Cases document and vote on publishing it as a first public working draft before W3C TPAC. Give fair notice of the vote immediately, start the vote at the end of the day on Tuesday October 14th 2014 and keep it open for 7 days.

Meeting for 2014-09-30

Topics

  1. Web Payments Use Cases Vote
  2. Register Now for W3C TPAC
  3. Advanced Use Cases (Tim Holborn)
  4. Offer use case
  5. Proof of Contribution Use Case
  6. Proof of Invention Use Case
  7. Wrapping up Use Cases

Meeting for 2014-09-23

Topics

  1. Complete Web Payments Use Case Review
  2. Identity Recovery
  3. Use Cases from Tim Holborn
  4. Generalized Credentials
  5. Read/Write Permissions
  6. Proof of Delivery
  7. Sharing Private Data
  8. Credential-based Access
  9. Confidential Sharing/Agreement
  10. Advertising and Data Rights
  11. Credentials for Internet of Things

Meeting for 2014-09-16

Topics

  1. W3C TPAC Preparation
  2. Mark as Liason to IMS Global and PESC
  3. Charter Vote Result
  4. Web Payments Use Case Review

Meeting for 2014-09-09

Topics

  1. Introduction of new Members
  2. Quick IGF 2014 Review
  3. Badge Alliance and JSON-LD Discussion
  4. Charter Vote Status
  5. Use Case Review

Meeting for 2014-08-26

Topics

  1. Introductions
  2. Overview of W3C Community Group Process
  3. Charter Review
  4. Questions Related to CG Operation
  5. Use Case Review

Resolutions

  1. Hold a vote on the Credentials CG Charter starting Friday, August 29th 2014 with the vote open for 2 weeks. Accept the charter if 2/3rds majority of votes cast are in favor.